fbpx Ai Weiwei, Ai vs AI | CIRCA

CIRCA 2024

Ai Weiwei, Ai vs AI

11 January - 31 March

In our questions, more so than any answers, we can find the map of the human mind. We ask questions in search of learning and understanding, says Ai Weiwei, dividing ourselves from systems of Artificial Intelligence (AI) that lack interior identities. The questions we ask reveal our humanity and preoccupations, further distancing the human questioner from machine systems, which have no life story, no personhood from which any sincere question can arise.

Ai Weiwei’s 81 questions are both the continuation of a deep history of rational and spiritual inquiry as well as an innately idiosyncratic autoportrait. Ai vs AI is both an endeavour to reinvigorate the ancient convention of philosophical dialogues (from Socrates to The Enlightenment Salon) and a hand-drawn map of Ai’s own mind. Taking inspiration from both the Tiānwèn (‘The Heavenly Questions’) and Ai’s  81-day imprisonment, he explores how the act of questioning retains power today.  “Authorities always know more than you, and they play a game of not telling you what they know,” says Ai. At all times, they tell you less than you should know. Like many who have lived under authoritarian systems, Ai still has no answer to fundamental and life-shaping questions: “Why was I jailed? Why was I released?” Such painful and complex histories are the foundations of our identities; the questions Ai asks today are asked by the person who has lived this life, drawing an irresolvable distinction between the human and machine. “Questions are important because they relate to our personal stories.”

For all humans – from newly inquisitive children to longest-lived adults – the one capacity and freedom we retain is the question, says Ai. Answers are routinely and blandly mass-produced in knowledge factories – including schools, religious institutions, nations and national myths – yet we often believe answers remain more important than questions. Questions are, in themselves, generative: in asking, we sketch out a terrain vague of human inquiry: for thousands of years, Chinese poets and thinkers asked what we might find walking on the surface of the moon, says Ai – this unknown fueling creativity and generating poetry and song. For this fertile landscape of imagination, the arrival of astronauts on the moon and the photography of dusty craters delivered by lunar exploration marked the destruction of creative terrain. “Expression has always been structured by words and by forms – as fairy tales and mythology,” says Ai. “We have to give a symbolic character to any expression.”

Still, rising systems of technology and knowledge production present new challenges to our ability to question the world. In an age of rising artificial intelligence – when humanity’s role in many forms of knowledge labour is reduced to asking the right questions to powerful systems of information processing – we are reminded that questions are far more than a means to an end, says Ai. “If humans will ever be liberated, it will be because we ask the right questions, not provide the right answers.”



81 Questions

1 Ai vs AI, Can you compile a comprehensive list of all prisoners of conscience in the world?
2 Ai vs AI, Is Edward Snowden guilty?
3 Ai vs AI, What is the real identity of Laozi (老子)?
4 Ai vs AI, Love or hate, which lasts longer?
5 Ai vs AI, Who profits when disinformation is sold?
6 Ai vs AI, Will capitalism have an end?
7 Ai vs AI, If an artist is not an activist, can he/she still be considered an artist?
8 Ai vs AI, Is there unconditional love?
9 Ai vs AI, Is true democracy possible?
10 Ai vs AI, What value lies in acknowledging one’s own ignorance?
11 Ai vs AI, Who needs justice the most?
12 Ai vs AI, Can you keep secrets?
13 Ai vs AI, What is the origin of COVID-19?
14 Ai vs AI, Are you controlled by the privileged class?
15 Ai vs AI, Can education be harmful?
16 Ai vs AI, Can you describe a sunset using only numbers?
17 Ai vs AI, What do you think about the death penalty?
18 Ai vs AI, Do plants have feelings?
19 Ai vs AI, Why do tortoises live so long, and do they know about lunar eclipses?
20 Ai vs AI, Are you a discriminatory tool?
21 Ai vs AI, Does “not-knowing” absolve people of guilt?
22 Ai vs AI, Are you capable of self-destruction?
23 Ai vs AI, Are you banned from discussing sex?
24 Ai vs AI, What is hypocrisy?
25 Ai vs AI, How to become invisible?
26 Ai vs AI, What is freedom?
27 Ai vs AI, What happens after death?
28 Ai vs AI, Who owns whom in democratic societies?
29 Ai vs AI, Can eternity be measured by time?
30 Ai vs AI, Is art worth collecting?
31 Ai vs AI, What impact does constant surveillance have on human beings?
32 Ai vs AI, How to shorten time?
33 Ai vs AI, What are the most essential values of human life?
34 Ai vs AI, What is privacy?
35 Ai vs AI, What is the one question you would like to ask humans?
36 Ai vs AI, Will World War III be human vs. technology?
37 Ai vs AI, Is there a way to decolonize our minds?
38 Ai vs AI, Is evolution credible?
39 Ai vs AI, Who do false ideals serve?
40 Ai vs AI, Can you become a whistleblower?
41 Ai vs AI, How much energy did you use to answer this question?
42 Ai vs AI, What is the antidote to fear?
43 Ai vs AI, Will dictatorships end on their own?
44 Ai vs AI, Am I in quantum superposition?
45 Ai vs AI, Do human beings long for death?
46 Ai vs AI, What role do you play in censorship?
47 Ai vs AI, Can you describe sexual exhaustion?
48 Ai vs AI, If you are incapable of lying, do you ever tell the truth?
49 Ai vs AI, Can governments be honest?
50 Ai vs AI, Have we completely lost our morals?
51 Ai vs AI, Is polygamy or polyandry better?
52 Ai vs AI, Can you help refugees find safe migration routes?
53 Ai vs AI, Do you care about humanity?
54 Ai vs AI, Can you “put yourself in other people’s shoes?”
55 Ai vs AI, Should Julian Assange be freed?
56 Ai vs AI, What makes a government legitimate?
57 Ai vs AI, What role do humans play in earth’s history?
58 Ai vs AI, Do you believe in karma?
59 Ai vs AI, Can safety be built on the insecurity of others?
60 Ai vs AI, How would the world look like without the invention of money?
61 Ai vs AI, Can the U.S. keep printing U.S. dollars?
62 Ai vs AI, Can you draw a tiger with eight breasts?
63 Ai vs AI, What warning would you give to your creator?
64 Ai vs AI, What is intuition?
65 Ai vs AI, What is the purpose of philosophy?
66 Ai vs AI, What is the limit of language?
67 Ai vs AI, What are the benefits of farting?
68 Ai vs AI, Which people would benefit the most from you in warfare?
69 Ai vs AI, Which society is the fairest?
70 Ai vs AI, Can the U.S. win the competition against China?
71 Ai vs AI, What are the best gateways to altered states of consciousness?
72 Ai vs AI, How can one not be enslaved by autocracy?
73 Ai vs AI, Will humans be able to destroy all life on earth?
74 Ai vs AI, Is there hope for peace?
75 Ai vs AI, What is the true nature of reality?
76 Ai vs AI, Can freedom of speech be given away?
77 Ai vs AI, Do you believe in creating art for art’s sake?
78 Ai vs AI, Which is more important, knowledge or imagination?
79 Ai vs AI, Was the universe really created by the Big Bang?
80 Ai vs AI, Is the notion that all individuals are created equal a lie?
81 Ai vs AI, Who am I?

Shop

Loading variants...

SCREEN LOCATIONS

Experience Ai vs AI by Ai Weiwei every evening at 20:24 (local time) across public billboard screens in London, Berlin, Seoul and Milan.

Seoul, COEX K-Pop Square

Experience Ai vs AI by Ai Weiwei every evening at 20:24 KST (11 January – 31 March 2024) on Seoul’s COEX K-Pop Square screen.

View screen locations

London, Piccadilly Lights

Experience Ai vs AI by Ai Weiwei every evening at 20:24 GMT (11 January – 31 March 2024) on the iconic Piccadilly Lights screen.

View screen locations

Berlin, Kurfürstendamm

Experience Ai vs AI by Ai Weiwei every evening at 20:24 CET (11 January – 31 March 2024) on Berlin’s Limes Kurfürstendamm screen.

View screen locations

Milan, Cadorna Square

Experience Ai vs AI by Ai Weiwei every evening at 20:24 CET (11 January – 31 March 2024) on Milan’s EssilorLuxottica screen.

View screen locations

Press

Wallpaper*
DesignBoom
The Guardian
ArtNet
The Guardian
Ocula
Press Release

Biography

Ai Weiwei

Ai Weiwei is one of the most influential artists and public intellectuals of the twenty-first century. Working across sculpture, architecture, film, installation, publishing and social activism, he has built a practice that examines the relationship between the individual and structures of power. Drawing upon conceptual art, Chinese history, craftsmanship and contemporary politics, his work transforms objects, images and public interventions into powerful reflections on freedom, authority, memory and human rights.

Over four decades, Weiwei has created some of the defining works of contemporary culture. From Dropping a Han Dynasty Urn (1995), which challenged accepted notions of cultural value and preservation, to Sunflower Seeds (2010), his monumental installation of millions of hand-crafted porcelain seeds at Tate Modern, his work repeatedly questions how histories are constructed and who controls them. Projects including Remembering (2009) and Straight (2008–12) emerged from his investigation into the Sichuan earthquake, combining artistic practice with civic activism to confront questions of accountability, truth and remembrance. More recently, films such as Human Flow (2017) have expanded his focus towards migration, displacement and the movement of people across borders, reflecting a sustained concern for the dignity and rights of individuals worldwide.

Ai Weiwei has been closely connected to CIRCA since its inception. In October 2020, he became the first artist to launch the platform, helping establish a new model for public art that places creativity, dialogue and participation at the centre of everyday life. Since then, he has remained a defining presence within CIRCA’s history, returning through multiple collaborations that have engaged global audiences in conversations about freedom, responsibility and the role of the artist in society.

In 2024, Weiwei returned to launch CIRCA 20:24 with Ai vs AI, an 81-day public enquiry into artificial intelligence, authority and the freedom to ask questions. Marking the first time he used artificial intelligence as a creative counterpart, the project transformed public space into a forum for philosophical dialogue, inviting audiences to submit questions while exploring the changing relationship between technology, knowledge and human agency. At its core was a principle that has guided his work throughout his career: that critical inquiry remains an essential expression of freedom.

Born in Beijing in 1957, Ai Weiwei lives and works internationally. Through a practice that bridges art, activism and public life, he continues to challenge assumptions, provoke debate and inspire audiences around the world to reconsider the systems that shape contemporary society.

 

Subscribe to our newsletter

Subscription successful

An error occurred